Proof by Contraposition

(Image Credit: Zeihen, Andy. “Lesson 5-4 Negation with Inverse and Contrapositive Statements.” Zeihen RMHS 605, 2026, www.zeihen.com/lesson-5-4-negation-with-inverse-and-contrapositive-statements.html. Accessed 8 Mar. 2026.)

In mathematics, we often want to prove statements of the form PQP\rightarrow Q, which reads “PP implies QQ.” Such a statement is true if QQ is true whenever PP is true, that is, when PP being true “forces” QQ to be true. An alternate but equivalent statement is the contrapositive ¬Q¬P\neg Q\rightarrow \neg P, which states that QQ being false implies that PP is false. This is useful because there are many times in which it is easier to prove the contrapositive of a statement rather than the statement itself. To show this, we’ll look at the following example:

if the square of an integer is even, then the integer must be even

Let nn\in\mathbb{Z} be an arbitrary integer. The direct approach would be to show that if n2=2k1n^2=2k_1 for some integer k1k_1 (n2n^2 is even), then n=2k2n=2k_2 for some integer k2k_2 (nn is even). The problem is that it’s hard to work from n2n^2 back to nn when dealing with integers because “just taking the square root” don’t give you the structural information you need to prove statements. Instead, it will be much easier to prove the contrapositive: if an integer is odd, then its square must be odd. Working from this direction, the proof boils down to some simple multiplication: If n=2k1+1n=2k_1+1 for some integer k1k_1 (nn is odd), then

n=2k1+1n2=4k12+4k1+1=2(2k12+2k1)+1=2k2+1\begin{align} n &= 2k_1+1 \\ n^2 &= 4k_1^2+4k_1+1 \\ &= 2(2k_1^2+2k_1)+1 \\ &= 2k_2+1 \end{align}

which shows that n2n^2 is odd. This is an example of how the most obvious or direct solution isn’t always the best one. Sometimes things click into place much easier when you look at them from another perspective.


Resources

  • “Contraposition.” Wikipedia, 18 Nov. 2021, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contraposition. Accessed 8 Mar. 2026.
  • Zeihen, Andy. “Lesson 5-4 Negation with Inverse and Contrapositive Statements.” Zeihen RMHS 605, 2026, www.zeihen.com/lesson-5-4-negation-with-inverse-and-contrapositive-statements.html. Accessed 8 Mar. 2026.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *